Picking the right marketing firm can either lift your business up or pull it down. A great firm boosts how well people know your brand, brings in more leads, and ups sales. But a bad choice can waste time and money. Here's how to find the best match:

1. Set Your Aims: Know what you need - be it more leads, higher sales, or better brand fame. Make goals that are clear, can be checked, can be met, are key, and are time-limited to lead your search.

2. Look at Their Skills: Check their past work, case works, and comments from others. Make sure they know your field and can show real results.

3. Check if You Match: Be sure their way of talking, values, and how they work fit with yours. Good teamwork is key.

4. Know Their Prices: Look at how they charge (by hour, by project, every month, or based on results). Pick one that suits your cash plan and aims.

5. Look at Tools and Tech: Check they use new tools like Google Analytics, HubSpot, or AI tools to get results.

6. Keep in Touch a Lot: Be clear about how often you want updates, reports, and ways to deal with hard times. Being open and regular meetings are key.

Fast Tip: Trust how you feel in the first meetings. If they ask smart questions and show a clear plan, it’s a good hint.

A good agency link can push real growth, but the wrong one can mess up your work. Use these six steps to pick wisely.

How to Choose a Digital Marketing Agency for 2025

1. Know What You Want in Your Marketing

Before you look for a marketing firm, it's key to know what you aim for. Set clear goals as they are the core of a good working bond and keep you from using up time and cash for no reason. If you skip this step, it’s very hard to know if a firm can match what you expect.

"Defining clear goals ensures that marketing efforts remain focused and aligned with business objectives." - Mack Media Group [1]

Think of your goals like a map. They lead you to places with skills in things like SEO, social media, or making content. They also help check if you are doing well as your plan moves on.

Know What Your Business Needs

Your marketing goals should match your main business aims. Say you want to raise your sales by 25% this year, you might need to look at getting more leads or keeping customers better. But, if you're moving into a new area, you should focus on making people know your brand.

Using SMART goals - Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound - can help a lot. Instead of just saying, "get more website visitors", set a clear goal like "raise organic website visits by 30% in six months." This makes sure you and your agency know what to aim for.

It’s key to also fix urgent problems. Are you not getting visitors to your site? Or are you getting visitors but no sales? Focus on the goals that make a fast difference.

There's proof for this. Firms with good sales and marketing working together grow 19% quicker and get 15% more profit. Plus, they are 67% better at making deals.

Spot What You’re Missing

Before asking others for help, look closely at what you’re doing now. Review internally to see what works and what doesn't, and where you can do better. Check your team's skill, the tools you use, how good your content is, and how well your marketing ways work. Getting info on strategy and work will show what you do well and what you don't.

For instance, in March 2023, Auto Revo saw they couldn't make enough good content on their own. They got help from CopyPress. Kevin Doory, SEO head at Auto Revo, said: “CopyPress lets us work with more dealership groups. We give them new, exciting content for a bigger number of customers.”

A SWOT analysis - looking at strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats - can also show where you need outside help. This might show you need an agency to better conversion rates or boost organic visits.

It’s important to note that 65% of marketing content is often not used by sales teams due to bad alignment. Fixing these issues is key to make sure your marketing supports your larger business goals.

Once you have clear goals and know your weak spots, you can well judge an agency's skills and history with more trust.

2. Know What the Agency Can Do

After you set your marketing aims, you need to check if the agency has what it takes to meet them. Look at their old work to see if they make good on what they say they can do.

Top agencies will show their win in your work area or with firms like yours. Why is this key? Because knowing your field well lets them grasp the hard parts and chances that are just for your kind of work.

"Picking a niche is actually about the client's ability to resonate with your services. The client needs to know that what you do speaks uniquely to them." – Alzay Calhoun, CovetedConsultant [3]

For example, the digital side of health care work was worth $9.8 billion in 2022. It keeps growing almost 10% each year [2]. Also, real estate folks spent over $655 million on ads in 2023 alone [2]. Teams that know a lot about these jobs can ask for big pay since they get good results.

To know more, look for real proof of good work through case studies and what clients say.

Check Case Studies and Results

Case studies are full of good info - if they're done well. They must show the client’s issue, what the team did, and the results. See them as a map that shows how the team solves problems and gets good outcomes.

If you're a small shop wanting more online sales, pick studies that match your scene. A plan for a big company might not fit since their money and plans are way different.

What builds a good case study?

Top case studies show clear numbers and times. For example: "The client began with 2,000 people coming to their site each month and a 1% buy rate. After six months of SEO and content work, visits went up to 8,000 a month with a 3.2% buy rate, making leads jump by 156%."

Look at the time too. Quick good stuff in a month is nice, but steady growth over six to twelve months shows better that the team can keep giving good results. Good studies also talk about hard spots and how they got past them.

What to watch out for:

Watch out for studies that look too perfect or too thin on details. If all results say "300% rise" or "top performance ever", it might be too much. Also, skip studies that skip the start point or what was needed to get those results.

After going through case studies, check what clients say to get a real feel of how the agency works with them.

Look at Client Words and Reviews

While numbers are in case studies, client words show what it’s like to work with the team. They tell about talks, trusting them, and how the team deals when plans fail.

Did you know 90% of people look at online reviews before buying? Even more, 74% say reviews make them trust a place more, and for B2B work like marketing teams, 97% of buyers lean on these client words and tips from pals [5][7].

Where to find real thoughts:

Don’t just stick to words on the team’s site - they pick only the best. Look at other places like Google Reviews, Clutch, or job-focused review sites. Social media is also good. Clients often share real takes on spots like LinkedIn or Twitter.

Watch how the team talks to bad reviews. Do they skip them, or do they answer well and try to fix things? A team that can deal with bad feedback well is more likely to take good care of your work.

What makes words from clients strong?

The best reviews are clear and to the point. For example, a review like "They upped our good leads by 40% in four months and got back to us in two hours" gives you clear info. Bland words like "great to work with" do not tell you much.

Look for words from clients who have stayed for a long time. These words show that the service can be trusted and changes when needed over time [6]. If most words are from short jobs, it may mean that clients do not stay.

Watch out for bad signs in reviews:

Be careful if all reviews look the same or use the same words. Real reviews will sound different and talk about different parts of the service. Also, if you see no bad reviews, it might mean the service hides bad feedback. Every place has unhappy clients - what is key is how they deal with them.

Only 23% of marketers are sure they are looking at the right numbers [4]. That is why it is key to pick a service that shows not just good numbers, but also happy clients to back up what they say.

3. Check How Well You Work Together

It is key to have a good agency help you, but it's very important to pick the right one. How both your team and the agency's team get along in their work style and what they think is right can be the thing that makes or breaks the work link [8].

Keep in mind, you will be working with these people for a lot of months or maybe years. If your ways or beliefs don't match, even the best plans can mess up. In truth, 86% of marketers mark that their big problem with digital marketing agencies is bad talk and not seeing the full truth [15].

"Hiring for mission and value alignment is arguably the most important piece of the puzzle to get right. If someone isn't inspired by your mission or on board with your values, then the employee won't feel as incentivized to contribute. Further, other employees will know if a new colleague isn't getting the culture or doesn't care and this can tear your company apart." - Greg Besner, founder of Sunflow and CultureIQ [9]

Test Fit in the First Meet

The first meeting is a good chance to see how well an agency works and talks. Don't just look at what they can do - watch how they deal with talks, solve problems, and if their core values match yours [11].

Ask them things like:

• How do they deal with hard talks with clients?

• Have they ever stopped working with a client, and why?

• How do they meet when you see things differently?

You can also feel their company vibe by looking at their social media, blog entries, or how they take part in the community. These spots can show what they value most [10].

Look at How They Talk and Show Clear Info

Good talking is key to any good team work. It's interesting that 78% of agencies say that keeping client hopes in line is tough time and time again during jobs [12]. When starting, notice how fast they get back to you on calls or emails and how straight they talk [14]. If they’re slow or not clear early on, it might be a sign of trouble later.

Being clear is just as big. Be sure the agency can easily share their plan, why they chose their ways, and what results they hope for.

"Transparency is vital because it positions agencies to involve clients in marketing efforts in a meaningful way." - Matt Hayes, Director of Client Services, Lucid Advertising [13]

Ask them how they report and how much they check in with news. Will you get reports often? How do they follow progress? The top groups don’t wait to be asked - they give news on their own. It's smart to set a sure talk plan before you agree to anything [12].

4. Check Prices and Get a Good Deal

Once you know what you want and see that the agency does well, look at how they charge. How they ask for money can really change how much you spend and what you get back (ROI). You don't just want the cheapest - you want a price that fits your needs and gives you the most for what you pay. Keep in mind: in 2023, firms spent about 9.1% of their money on marketing, so picking right is important [19].

Look at Different Price Plans

Marketing firms use many ways to set prices, each with its own good and bad points. Knowing which way works best for what you need helps you pick wisely.

• Hourly rates: Firms charge by the hour for work done. For example, a new writer may cost $90 per hour, while a top creative person could be $300 per hour [16].

• Project-based pricing: This sets a price for a certain job. Like, redoing a website might cost between $25,000 and $60,000, based on how hard it is [16].

• Retainer agreements: Good for long plans, this way gives steady pricing. Small firms often pay about $5,000 a month, while bigger businesses might pay $12,000 each month [16].

• Performance-based pricing: Pay is based on what you achieve, like more leads or sales, making sure the agency's aims match yours.

• Agile sprint pricing: A new way where you pay for quick, intense work runs. A two-week run on strategy, content, and ads could be $18,000 [16].

Here's a fast look at the good and bad of each way:

Look At ROI and What You Get

Aside from cost, think about what you gain from what you pay. Good firms will list what they will give you and show their success with real numbers. Ask them for past wins like more visits to your site or more sales, and check that they give you clear, frequent updates on how things are going. Top firms do more than just show numbers - they change plans based on what the data tells them.

To understand if the cost is fair, looking at what others in your field spend can help. For example, B2B firms often use 2%-5% of their money on marketing, which is less than many other fields [19]. Big growing accounting groups might spend about 2% of their money on marketing (not counting the cost of their team) and up to 3% with those costs [20].

Firms charge different amounts too:

• Digital marketing firms: $2,500–$12,000 each month

• SEO firms: $500–$30,000 each month

• Social media marketing: $1,000–$20,000 each month

• Branding work: $10,000–$50,000 [17]

Being open is important. Firms that are good to team up with will be clear about how they set prices and how this meets your needs. It's worth noting, 43% of firms use mixed ways of setting prices [18], putting together fixed fees with bonuses for results or charges for specific jobs. This mix can show their real drive to meet what you need.

5. Check Tech and Tools Used by the Agency

The right tools and tech are now a must in marketing. The need for high-tech ways to track, check, and make better plans across many ways of sharing info is big today. Agencies stuck with old or weak tools will probably not get the results you want. But those who use the newest tech can really help your business.

Let's look deeper into the tools and tech to find in a marketing agency.

Look at Marketing Tech and Data Tools

Data tools are key for any good marketing plan. They grab and sort your data, showing which lines of work, ways, and plans work best [23]. When you ask an agency, check what tech they use and how their tools work together. The top ones mix data from many places, using platforms like Google Analytics for how a website is doing, Ahrefs for SEO checks, and Hotjar for seeing how users act [21]. Find agencies that show data well and mix tech without much cost [23].

Mixing is important. Tim Akers, who started Akers Digital, talks about the hard parts his agency saw:

"Finding a platform that worked with our entire tech stack was a struggle. Email, DSP, Google Ads, Social, eComm, Analytics, and more. But we found it with AgencyAnalytics. Plus, if an integration is missing the support team is AMAZING in helping us." [26]

Brad Russell, who started Digital Hitmen, says that being able to report is just as key:

"Most reporting platforms don't have the ability to include data from all components of a digital campaign. It was vital to measure and report on SEO, social, paid search, CRM, and email marketing. The ability to do this is critical for our clients." [26]

Agencies should use sites like HubSpot for marketing and numbers, Meltwater for tracking talks across sites, or Mixpanel for app and site use checks [21]. These tools should work as one, stop data traps and let you see all of your work.

Look for New Tech and Change Room

To stay top in marketing, you must keep up with fresh tech. The field changes fast, and agencies must shift to stay in the game. For example, by the end of 2024, making AI is set to be a main part of almost all big software, adding about $10 billion to the money big software groups make [24]. Agencies that get these tools early are set to win.

AI is key now. Right now, 54% of marketers use AI, and 70% of top marketing folk plan money for AI tools [24][25]. Jim Lecinski, a big teacher of marketing at Kellogg School of Management, says this:

"Rather than seeing AI as this dystopian view as peddled by Elon Musk of robots coming to take our jobs, they will carry out tasks for you. They're not particularly creative. They're not particularly strategic. They don't operate well on small amounts of information. There's a few models that are getting better at it, but they can't think like we do." [25]

Companies must also get ready for big changes in how people act. By 2026, usual search hits may fall by 25%, and 79% of folks might use AI to help search in the next year [25]. Now is the time for firms to make plans for these shifts. They need to focus on getting good results from AI-led search, also known as Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) [25].

Look for firms that use top tools like Brandwatch and Sprinklr for AI-led mood checks, or tools like Mutiny to make web pages with no need to code [22]. The top firms mix old ways with new tech to make strong marketing plans.

Being able to change is key too. Dr. Richard Girling, the boss of Red Castle Services, says:

"Software and technologies are constantly changing, meaning that - on top of keeping our clients happy - we need to find time for upskilling. But this has been aided by the flexibility of AgencyAnalytics, which has been quick to integrate new software, keeping all data centralized for client simplicity." [26]

Ask the group how they keep up with new tech and how they test and use new tools. The right group should have a good plan to stay on top of new things like AI, big-scale custom work, and online selling. A solid set of tech tools is not just good to have - it's key to match the group's skills with what your business aims to do.

6. Look at How You Talk and Share Info

Good talk and often sharing updates are key for a good team work with a marketing firm. To really know how your plans are doing, how your cash is spent, and what you are getting, being open and honest is a must. A good agency will tell you about both good and bad things, owning up to how they do.

Set Rules for Updates

To start a strong way of talking, pick how often you want news. Study shows that 46% of agencies give monthly updates to their clients, while 18% check in every three months, and 14% meet every week[28].

Terrence Gordon, CEO of 214Interactive.com, says why monthly updates might be the best way:

"Our clients understand (through setting expectations) that a monthly frequency is the default. Although each client is different, a higher frequency of data reduces the ability to deduce trends and evaluate effectiveness. It may prompt hasty decisions that skew trend analysis." [27]

Yet, how often we talk is just part of it. You must pick the best ways to talk, too. Some groups use things like Teams or Slack for fast, day-to-day news, while some like emails or calls. Pick what works best with how you work and makes things clear.

On reports, they need to be simple to get and ready to use. Daniel Dye, who leads Native Rank, Inc., gives his view:

"Focus on creating reports that are clear, concise, and actionable. This means using data visualization tools like charts, graphs, and tables to help clients quickly and easily understand the performance of their campaigns so clients can understand what the data means and how it relates to their business goals." [27]

For example, Delmain, a web ad firm, moved to AgencyAnalytics in 2020. They cut the time to make reports from 90 minutes for each client every month to just 30 minutes. This not only saved time but also made clients happier. Plus, make sure you can get to the basic data from these reports, so you can look into the details if you need to.

Other than usual updates, it's key to have a good plan ready for hard times.

Make a Plan for Solving Issues

Even with steady reports, problems can pop up. Ads might not do well, deadlines may be missed, or there might be big disagreements on plans. What's key is to have a strong plan to take on these issues and a way to spot possible problems early.

Dylan Hey, CEO of Hey Digital, points out how important it is to stay on top of problems:

"Being proactive in suggesting optimizations and new strategies shows that the agency is committed to continuous improvement and delivering long-term value. We call that 'advisory value,' and we believe it is what separates us from other commoditized agencies." [29]

Hey also says we need clear and full reports:

"Agencies must learn to provide in-depth monthly reporting that clearly demonstrates performance metrics, revenue impact, and return on investment. Your clients should receive meaningful metrics." [29]

When things go bad, your agency must be set to tell you what broke, why it did, and how they plan to fix it. This way, their work stays in line with your big business goals. Keep this in mind, only about 10% of clients know data well[28], so reports that make hard facts easy to use are worth a lot.

Last, good talks are not just about planned news. The top agencies answer fast when you ask stuff and do not wait to update you on big choices[30]. They handle your business with as much speed and care as if it were their own, making sure you know what's happening always.

End: Picking the Best Fit

Choosing the right agency is more than just checking off boxes - it's about finding a partner who really understands your business. The six ways we talked about offer a clear plan to help you pick, both in terms of strategy and personal fit.

Spend time to make sure the agency you pick shows the true spirit of your brand. Check their website, case studies, and past work to see if they match your needs and values. Before you start talks, list your top two or three business aims. Be ready to tweak these goals together as you look at possible partnerships.

Trust and talking are vital. Did you know 89% of people think companies can build trust or get it back by being honest about mistakes and how they fix them? [31] This idea also fits with agency ties. Think about this: in 1984, client-agency ties lasted about seven years. Now, they last less than three years [12]. A big problem is lack of joining, with 28% of CMOs saying it's tough in their ties [12]. These facts show how key clear talk is from the start.

Be clear about your money. Talk openly about what you can spend and the results you hope for. While you might want to pick the cheapest, remember good work costs more. A strong agency can give back much more than you put in.

Watch how they act in early meetings. Does the agency ask deep questions? Do they listen well and explain their plan in ways you get? These hints show they really want to get your business.

In the end, the right choice will just feel right. You'll know you've picked well when they get your aims, talk clearly, and want to grow like you do. Trust your gut - if something feels wrong early, it could mean trouble later.

A great agency tie can lift your marketing and bring real business wins. But the wrong pick can waste your time, money, and chances. Use these six ways to guide you to the best choice for your needs and aims.

FAQs

How can I pick a marketing firm that fits my business values and the way we talk?

To find a marketing firm that fits with what your business cares about and how you like to talk, begin by setting out what matters most to your firm. List your values and how you like to talk. This will help you choose the right firms later.

When you start to talk to firms, ask them what values they hold dear and how these values guide their work. Look into their past work and what clients say about them - this may show if they work in a way that matches your style and what's important to you.

Watch how they talk to you while you pick. Are they on time, straight, and easy to work with? talk about what you expect early on, like how often you should talk. A good firm will care about open, ongoing talks and will be open to matching your business needs.

How can I find out the ROI when picking a marketing agency with different price tags?

How to Know the ROI When Picking a Marketing Agency

To learn the ROI from a marketing agency, start by making clear, simple goals that fit with your business aims. Ask yourself: What does a win look like for your company? It could be more sales, more people interested, or a better-known brand. When you know this, pick what numbers you can use to track how well things are going - like more sales, how often customers come back, or how much you save.

Then, look closely at how the agency sets its prices. Do they charge by the hour, by the project, keep a steady fee, or get paid based on results? A results-based choice might look good because it links costs right to results, making it easy to see how your money leads to real gains. To check the ROI, stack up the entire cost of their work against the extra money they pull in or the costs they cut down. This will show you clearly if working together is a smart move.

By looking into these points, you can pick wisely in a way that meets your goals and helps your business grow.

Related posts

• Digital Marketing Budget Guide for Small Businesses

• Content Marketing vs Social Media: What to Prioritize

• How Case Studies Build Trust Through Storytelling

• Unified Brand Messaging: Why It Matters